Meet Our Team

Scott Kinder

Managing Partner



Scott Kinder is from Sumter, SC. He joined CRW Insurance in 2008 as Benefits coordinator assisting in Life and Health coverage for groups and individual. Scott purchased the agency in 2016 with Robbie Nalley and serves in various roles promoting CRW Insurance. He is married to Cristi Kinder and they have 3 children and 9 grandchildren. He loves the outdoors and enjoys hunting and spending time on the water. He is a member or Christ Community Church where he serves as an usher and is also on the Welcome team. Scott is member of the Progressive club and the Palmetto Rotary Club of Sumter.

Robbie Nalley

Managing Partner



Robbie Nalley grew up in Clarendon County attending school in Manning, SC and church in Sumter, SC. After graduating The Citadel in 1991 Robbie spent 9 years as a teacher, coach and athletic director. In 2000 he began working as a producer at CRW Insurance and in 2016 became a co-owner of the business. Robbie is active in the IIABSC and currently serves as the secretary for its Board of Directors. Robbie is married with 2 girls and attends Christ Community Church. In his free time, he enjoys hunting and fishing.

Commercial Lines
Donna Jo Smith

Department Manager



Donna Jo Smith joined CRW Insurance in April 2018 as a Commercial Lines Customer Service Representative. She is the commercial lines department manager and has over 20 years of experience in property casualty insurance. She obtained her CISR designation in 1997 and her CIC designation in 2011. She is responsible for servicing Commercial property and casualty clients and ensuring our clients obtain individualized service that meets their coverage with competitive rates. Donna Jo has a son named Timothy & she enjoys shopping, reading & spending time with family & friends.

April Preator

Account Manager



April Preator made Sumter, SC her home in 2004, relocating from Tyler, TX. She has performed many roles in the Insurance Industry in both Personal and Commercial Lines. She is now a Commercial Lines Account Manager and has been with CRW since 2018. Her favorite things about the organization are the personal relationships they develop with clients and the family atmosphere in the workplace.

In her free time, April enjoys being with her husband and children and spending time with her family. She loves the ocean, photography, visiting new places and leaving kindness along the way.

“God is within her; she will not fall.” Psalm 46:5

Sandi White




Sandi White has lived in Sumter, since 1971, when her stepfather was stationed at Shaw Air Force Base. Born in the Smokie Mountains of Tennessee, then moved to the Chicago area. Joined the VFW Auxiliary and after serving in various offices of the local post she served as the Department President from 1991-1992. With that, she has visited all over the state of SC and many other interesting places in our great country.

Sandi has been working for CRW since 2009, as the Commercial Lines Processor (and many other flunky jobs. Ha Ha!). She enjoys baking and sharing with other folks.

Jennifer Rogers

Account Manager



Jennifer Rogers was raised in Rembert, SC and spent a lot of her childhood years in Camden, SC. She has called Sumter home for over 10 years. She met her husband in Sumter and they have four fur-babies.

Jennifer has a background in Medical Billing and Coding that she received from Central Carolina Technical College. She was in that field for 10 years in a Long-Term Care setting. She joined the CRW team in 2019 as the receptionist and is now a Commercial Account Manager. She enjoys the challenges and learning experiences in insurance. She strives to keep learning new information that will help her be a better agent. Her favorite thing about CRW Insurance is the family-like atmosphere.

When Jennifer is not working, she enjoys spending her summers at Lake Marion or Lake Wateree. She looks forward to football season and goes to as many Gamecock games as she can. She loves spending time with her family and friends. Jennifer has a huge heart for animals and tries to find homes or rescue as many as she can.

Quote to live by: Every day may not be good, but there is something good in every day. -Alice Morse Earl

Brandi Sloan

Account Manager



Brandi Sloan recently joined CRW Team in December 2020.  She brings over 22 years of experience in Commercial Lines insurance.  She earned her Accredited Advisor in Insurance (AAI) designation in 2004.

She was born and raised in Sumter, SC but found her home in the Lee County where she enjoys the "country life" with her husband Steve and their dogs.  She likes working outdoors and tending to her organic garden.  Brandi was blessed with musical talent and loves to play the violin (and most recently the accordion) for others.  She has been a member of The Woman's Afternoon Music Club since 2016 and serves as their Treasurer.

One of her favorite Bible verses is "Therefore encourage one another and build each other up..." 1 Thes 5:11

Angela Young




Angela Young has been in South Carolina for a year now. Both her dad and her husband currently serve in the Military and as a dependent she has lived in several states and countries. She joined our team as front desk and currently works as a Processor for the Commercial Lines team. Her favorite thing about our organization is our family friendly environment and that all of her coworkers are always willing to help each other.

While away from work, Angela loves spending time with her husband and her two daughters and kitten. She also enjoys running 5K’s and half marathons, working out, shopping, and cooking.

Quote to live by: “Make your life a masterpiece; imagine no limitations on what you can be, have or do. “- Brian Tracy

Personal Lines
Alexis Smithhart

Service Team



Alexis Smithhart has lived all over the world calling many places home, but Sumter is her favorite. As a military dependent, she has gotten to see some of the most beautiful places around the world which ignited her love for the beach and mountains. She joined our team at Creech Roddey Watson Insurance in August of 2020 where she serves on the Retention Team in Personal Lines. Her favorite thing about CRW is how everyone is so encouraging and like family. When not at work, you can find her watching the sunset, enjoying a Hallmark movie, or spending time with her family. She serves on the greeting team along with the CCC kids’ team at Christ Community Church here in Sumter.

Her favorite Bible verse is: “He will cover you with his feathers, and under his wings you will find refuge; his faithfulness will be your shield and rampart.” -Psalm 91:4

Ansley Ridgill

New Business Team



Ansley Ridgill is a proud graduate of the University of South Carolina. Ansley holds her Property and Casualty insurance license and is an asset to our personal lines team. She loves to shop, clean, and organize in her free time, and you can always find her at every home Gamecock football game!

Ruth Hickman




Ruth moved to Sumter in 1973 making this her permanent home. As a military dependent, she enjoyed traveling and now calls Sumter her home after her father retired here. Graduated from Sumter High School and got married shortly after graduation and started raising a family. She joined Creech Roddey Watson in 2006 and is a Personal Lines Processor. While away from the office, she enjoys spending time with her husband, children, and grandchildren. Enjoys cooking and relaxing on weekends, enjoys downtime.

Favorite prayer to live by:

Serenity Prayer

God, grant me

Serenity to accept the things I cannot change

Courage to change the things I can, and

Wisdom to know the difference.

Jamie Phegley

Retention Team



Jamie Phegley joined the CRW team in June of 2020 as a Personal Lines Account Manager. She earned her Bachelor’s Degree in Insurance & Risk Management from Indiana State University and has over 20 years of insurance industry experience.

In her spare time, you can find Jamie cruising the open seas with her husband or just relaxing at home with her basset hound, Millie. She also enjoys spending time with her four adult children. Jamie attends MCC church where she serves on the greeting team and is a member of Tri Kappa.

Stacy Marsh

Service Team



Stacy Marsh was born and raised in Sumter, South Carolina. She is a wife to her husband, Ryan, and has three wonderful children. Stacy graduated from Sumter High School in 1999. She has had a career in insurance for the last seven years and looks forward to many more. She currently holds the position of Servicing Representative for Creech Roddey Watson Insurance Agency.

When not in the office, Stacy enjoys spending time with her family and friends. They love to fish, ride four wheelers, and visit state parks. She and her husband love visiting Edisto. Stacy’s favorite time of year is Christmas, especially the lights. She enjoys decorating her Christmas tree and cooking for her family and friends. Stacy attends Sumter Freewill Baptist of the Pentecostal Faith and loves her church family.

Stacy Spurling

New Business Team



Stacy Spurling, was born and raised in Sumter, SC. She has been married for 23 years to Chad and they have 2 sons Michael and Alex. Stacy often says her home life is like a zoo, as she has 3 dogs and 1 cat that she loves dearly. Stacy joined the CRW team in October of 2018, after being in the insurance industry for 20 years. She speaks fluent Spanish and loves helping others.

Stacy currently serves as a Senior Account Manager in personal lines. She is part of the Helping Hands committee, where she serves the role of putting together work and community actions, giving back to Sumter County and surrounding areas. Away from work, Stacy enjoys the beach, shopping, and Mexican food! Stacy attends Newspring Church in Florence SC, where she uses her hospitality serving on their greeting team.

Favorite Bible verse: Psalm 14:3-8 “Let the morning bring me word of your unfailing LOVE, for I have put my trust in you. Show me the way I should go, for to you I entrust my life.”

Amber Stevens

Life and Health



Amber Stevens, originally from the small town of Cassatt, SC, currently resides in Rembert of Sumter County. She joined our team in June of 2020 and is one of our Benefit Coordinators for our Life and Health Department. When asked what her favorite things about our office were, Amber insisted that it is our family- focused values, the friendliness of her coworkers, and the willingness everyone has to go above and beyond for their clients.

In her spare time, Amber takes advantage of spending it with her husband and three kids. They enjoy fulfilling activities in their family’s Adventure Book, cooking/ baking, having movie nights and enjoying the outdoors.

Kay Jowers

Retention Team



Kay Jowers is a proud lifelong South Carolina resident and has been in the insurance industry for 32 years. Kay has worked for two different insurance agencies, which has built her very strong personal lines experience, and she is an account manager. Kay enjoys her free time at her home by the water and with her two granddaughters!

Brittany Tindal




Brittany Tindal is originally from Sumter, South Carolina where she attended Wilson Hall and went on to graduate from Clemson University. She began her career in insurance over 15 years ago and has worked in personal, life, and commercial departments. Brittany currently is a full time Producer for our office. You can find Brittany boating with her family or horseback riding in her down time.

Terri Richburg




Terry Richburg is a native of Manning, South Carolina where he has owned his own business for 35 years. He decided to diversify, getting into the insurance business in 2003 and currently holds both his P&C and Life licenses, and he is a Producer for our office. Terry enjoys any time off at his home on the lake with wife Becky, and their four children: Emily, Jacob, Abby, and Anna.

Will Watson




Will Watson has spent the entirety of his life in Sumter, South Carolina. Will joined our team in May of 2019, after graduating from The Citadel, The Military College of South Carolina. He is part of our outside sales team, which entails assessing risks and developing lasting relationships. Two of his favorite aspects of this organization include the constant educational and team focused environment.

Outside of the agency, Will values spending time with friends and family. He enjoys sports and appreciates the outdoors. He can be found spending his downtime hunting, camping, or on the water.

Administrative & Accounting
Kelly Wenzel

Office Manager



Kelly Wenzel, born and raised in Passaic, NJ and went to college in Wilson, NC and studied business administration. Kelly received her P&C license in 2010 and has been growing within the industry ever since. Kelly has two children that she loves dearly and keep her on her toes. In my free time I like to cook and give back to the community. Kelly is very strong and positive influence for our clients and employees.

Joe Sicard




Joe Sicard, I have been a resident of Sumter County since 2017. My family and I moved here for the great weather and found great people as well. I Graduated from California State University of Fresno with a B.S. in Finance and spent 25 years in corporate Accounting. I came to work at CRW in 2019 and found a group of people that approach each day with a sense of urgency to care for their customers and community.

Kathy Walker

Administrative Assistant



Kathy Walker is originally from Connecticut and has been in much warmer South Carolina for the past five years. Kathy bring to us over 30 years of customer service experience! She is the smiling face that greets you when you visit our office. Kathy has one son and spends her free time gardening, crocheting, and cooking.

Debbie Hunter

Bookkeeper / Controller



Debbie Hunter has been a lifelong resident of Sumter where she graduated from Wilson Hall in 1980 and then attended Converse College. She joined CRW in 1996 and has served as our bookkeeper since 1999.

In addition to spending family time with her husband, two children and new grandson, she also enjoys spending time with her two golden fur-babies. They love to go RVing with mom and dad, especially to their fav destination spot and take long walks on the beach. Cooking and catching up on a favorite author are also two of her favorite past-times.

Quote: “What you see will violate what you know unless what you know dictates what you see.” - Author unknown

Hayley Moore

Administrative Assistant



Hayley was born and raised in Sumter, SC. At the age of 24, she joined our team as our Front Desk Receptionist in October of 2020. She has been working in customer service for 7 years. Her favorite thing about our business is the teamwork the members of the company show, the commitment to quality service, and working in an office so close to her home.

While away from work, Hayley enjoys spending time with her family and her son, Rowan. On the weekends, you can find her shopping, taking trips to the beach, or curling up at home with a good book.

Quote to live by: “If I rise on the wings of the dawn, if I settle on the far side of the sea, even there your hand will guide me.” – Psalms 139:9-10

25 East Calhoun Street
P.O. Box 70
Sumter, South Carolina 29151
Phone: 803-775-1168
Fax: 803-773-8855
Hours of Operation
Monday - Friday
8:30 am - 5:00 pm
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon



Creech Roddey Watson Insurance | All Rights Reserved | Privacy Policy